MarinersTalk40 #11 -- Stefen Romero, 2b [3b? 1b? OF?]

MarinersTalk40 #11 -- Stefen Romero, 2b [3b? 1b? OF?]

Wherefore art thou not in the top 10, Romero?


2013 Age: 23 ... 6-foot-2, 220 ... drafted in the 12th round of the 2011 draft out of Oregon State

Cheesy catchphrase: Leave it to the Beaver!

*** Stat Line:

2011 22 Clinton MIDW A SEA 116 478 429 120 22 4 16 65 16 9 32 69 .280 .342 .462 .803
2012 23 2 Teams 2 Lgs A+-AA SEA 116 516 474 167 34 7 23 101 12 5 27 72 .352 .391 .599 .991
2 Seasons       232 994 903 287 56 11 39 166 28 14 59 141 .318 .368 .534 .901
Provided by View Original Table
Generated 3/31/2013.

Key 2012 splits imported from


Spectometer STAT-Scan:

More explanation of the stats here.  If you find this too small, at least in Firefox you can right-click and click "View Image" to enlarge (not sure about other browsers).  Essentially, the more color the better.


Moving Pictures:

Mariners Prospect Stefen Romero



Fun Facts to Know and Tell:

  • Romero did not join the Beavers until after their unlikely back-to-back national championships in 2006 and 2007.
  • The 2007 North Carolina team vanquished by the pre-Romero Beavers did include a trio of freshmen named Ackley, Seager and Moran (see below).
  • The greatest ex-Beaver of all time is probably Jacoby Ellsbury, which I guess tells you how many successful major leaguers have come from there.  Next would be '70s Astro Ken Forsch who had a 3.37 ERA but a 114-113 record.


Bottom Line:

Three Numbers (confused? help here): Plate Skills: 97  Production: 127  Composite:  124

Funny thing with Stefen Romero.  A year ago at this time, he was squarely on my radar, and I put him in the initial Talk40 at No. 32.  At the time, I think Gordon and Lonnie were the only other ones even mentioning him.

Then, all of the sudden, he became a sensation and everyone is ranking him near the top.  Now, I'm in the position of having to explain why I don't have him as high as everyone else.

[But, first of all, understand that I do have him ranked really high.  It's not like there's tons of extra room in the Top 10.]

But here goes:

  • He's reluctant to draw enough walks.  That's not just a High Desert thing.  It was at Oregon State, Clinton and Jackson, too.  Except for one season at OSU ... under 7%.  The failure to consistently draw walks was the main reason that the "Spectometer" projected that Jose Lopez would not have long-term MLB success.
  • One of the most consistent things I've found is that hitters need to show the ability to get either  an extra-base hit or a walk at least 19% of the time in the minors.  If they don't, they're relying too much on singles.  Even in Romero's awesome 2012, he only reached 17.6% in that category, because of the low walk rate.  If he's going to keep walking under 7% he puts a huge amount of pressure on himself to hit.
  • Another thing I've found is that there is often (not invariably) reason for skepticism when a guy doesn't bust out in the minors until age 23.  At that age, he is almost always older and more experienced than his opposition.  It's one reason I never warmed up to Casper Wells.  He never put up interesting stats until he was old for his level.

So Romero has the "Jose Lopez" red flag (perpetual low BB%) and the "Casper Wells" red flag (lukewarm until age 23, then bust out).

But ...

Romero struggled with injuries at Oregon State that held back his placement, and that helps explain why he was still at High-A at age 23.  And ... he has a major "sleeper" indicator, which is: generating a ton of power with a very low K%.   And ... he played every game at 2b and ought to handle 3b, which gives him a great deal of value over a guy without that versatility.

So I'm not against him, I'm just a tad more skeptical than most, and that doesn't mean that I'm denying there are lots of positive signs.


And finally:

Here's the last out from 2007.  Dustin Ackley made the next-to-last out.

Oregon State Beavers are the College World Series Champions!